[zeromq-dev] PUB message HWM dropping policy
algrant at acm.org
Wed Aug 8 13:33:17 CEST 2018
The docmentation of zmq_socket states:
"When a *ZMQ_PUB* socket enters an exceptional state due to having
reached the high water mark for a *subscriber*, then any messages
that would be sent to the *subscriber* in question shall instead be
dropped until the exceptional state ends."
I can see two diametrically opposite ways of reading that:
(a) the next message which would otherwise be sent from ZMQ
queue to the subscriber, will be dropped until the exceptional
state is resolved - i.e. messages will be dropped _oldest_ first
(b) messages which the user sends to the ZMQ queue e.g. using
zmq_send will be ignored until the exceptional state is resolved -
i.e. messages will be dropped _newest_ first
Could this be clarified? In my current application I want the
"oldest first" behavior. I want to be able to call zmq_send
and never block, and if necessary have ZMQ drop messages
oldest first in order not to block. But I'm not confident I can
read enough formal specification of behavior into the docs to
rely on it.
(I know about ZMQ_CONFLATE but I need to handle overflow
on the sender side too.)
Also, the categorization of message loss at
doesn't mention HWM-related dropping at all. It surely ought to cover the
cases when messages are dropped for overflow reasons.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the zeromq-dev