[zeromq-dev] Idea: custom encoder/decoder for STREAM sockets

Goswin von Brederlow goswin-v-b at web.de
Sat Feb 1 13:42:31 CET 2014


Hi,

zmq is a message based protocol and application always recieve
messages as a whole.

Not so with ZMQ_STREAM sockets. There the application gets the data in
whatever chunks it happens to arrive. Sometimes even a byte at a time
if that is how it comes in.

Now often the data transmitted on a ZMQ_STREAM socket has some
structure. For example HTTP traffic is made up of lines terminated by
\r\n and those lines make up requests also terminates by \r\n (so you
get \r\n\r\n at the end of a request). And replies have a header (same
\r\n encoding) and content.

So wouldn't it be neat if zmq_msg_recv() could block until a full HTTP
request was recieved and deliver that as either a single message frame
or already split by lines into key:value pairs? Similar for the reply,
it could be 2 frames: One for the header and one for the content.


Now I'm not suggesting to add a HTTP protocol parser to zmq. That is
not its job. But zmq internally already has some meachnism that covers
a range of different zmq protocol versions using different encoders
and decoders. Why not allow the user to specify encoder and decoder
callbacks for ZMQ_STREAM sockets? Then other protocols like HTTP could
be implemented as custom encoder/decoder and passed to zmq for use.

Thoughts?

MfG
	Goswin



More information about the zeromq-dev mailing list